Beware Canadian Taxpayer tea party

The Canadian Taxpayers’ Federation is right to raise alarms about the growing inequity between generous pensions paid politicians and the reality too many in the private sector have inadequate, or no pensions …

Uh… right…

That isn’t exactly what the libertarian-when-it-suits-them CTF has its knickers in a knot about.

METRO LOGO GREEN

The CTF—which bills itself as a “not-for-profit citizen’s group dedicated to lower taxes, less waste and accountable government”—opened its new Atlantic office last week with a splashy “study” claiming provincial taxpayers fork out $22 for every dollar MLAs contribute to their pension plans.

If that is true—the CTF is infamous for simplistic statistical jiggery-pokery—it is outrageous. Even if it isn’t precisely true-true, it reflects a larger truth. Over the past few decades, our politicians have quietly created a cocooned world of privilege for themselves. The CTF has been foraging in this fertile swamp of government waste and inefficiency since 1990.

But making governments work better isn’t the CTF’s goal.

The CTF—which takes its ideological cues from American neo-cons—sees government as the enemy.

Public spending on public services like education, health care, highways, social programs, industrial development? Bad. The CTF has never met a tax it thought couldn’t be reduced or, better, eliminated.

Except… the CTF is selectively libertarian. It campaigns against the ”expensive” long-gun registry, for example, but seems untroubled by Ottawa’s much more costly political-sop plan to build more prisons while actual crime rates decline.

The CTF made political hay with last winter’s MLA expenses scandal but barely acknowledged that the same provincial auditor general’s report flagged an extra $52 million Nova Scotia taxpayers shelled out to private contractors for so-called P3 schools.

Though it claims to be non-partisan, the CTF is a revolving door for right-wing Tory hacks. Jason Kenny was CTF’s CEO before becoming a Tory MP. CTF’s current national spokesperson was Reform Party leader Preston Manning’s Research Director. Kevin Lacey, CTF’s new Atlantic Director, previously worked for both Stephen Harper and John Hamm (the latter, interestingly, during the time when MLA pensions got their gold plating).

So, while the CTF raises a valid issue, we should be wary of being invited to its tea party.

 

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2010 Stephen Kimber, Website
  1. Indeed, beware the Canadian Taxpayer’s Federation (CTF). Statistical jiggery-pokery is exactly how to describe their claim that NS taxpayers pay $22 for every dollar MLAs contribute to their pension plans, when it is clear that the actual figure is $6.79. While it may be true that this is still too high and requires review, it is typical of the CTF to skew their arguments, and this distortion of the facts is typical.

    Also, while the CTF decries the “expensive long-run registry (which costs $4.1 million/year to run) they support the federal government’s plans to spend $16 billion to purchase F-35 jets. Its seems their arithmetic is completely dependant on their ideology. To call this right-wing, libertarian lobby group a “taxpayer watchdog” would be a misnomer indeed.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *